Error message

Deprecated function: The each() function is deprecated. This message will be suppressed on further calls in _menu_load_objects() (line 579 of /home/deardea1/public_html/drupal7/includes/menu.inc).

Moral Outrage

August 4, 2009 - 2:06pm -- swingbug

Totally moral outrage!  Infamy, heresy, and blasphemy! The world has gone insane and I'm surrounded by heathens. How and when did this happen?

I was having a perfectly normal sci-fi conversation with a friend – who shall remain nameless – when this friend, whom I generally consider to be intelligent and well-informed, had the gaul to say that Firefly creator Joss Whedon "pioneered the whole cowboys in outer space thing."

Dude. This is someone I know. How is that possible?

I turned to another trusted compatriot in indignation. This also-unnamed person said, “Deep Space Nine was kinda a western.”

Star Trek? Are you serious?

Now I’m not arguing that Firefly was anything but an absolutely fantastic piece of programming and a most successful setting of a western in space. Nor do I deny that Deep Space Nine had very intentional similarities to a frontier town both in setting and character. These are givens. Accepted. Noted. Fine.

But Han Solo clearly predates and sets the bar for every space cowboy that came after him. The Millennium Falcon was already doing laps around the galaxy before either Captains Benjamin Sisko or Malcolm Reynolds were even a glimmer in their creators’ eyes and if Joss Whedon didn’t base Mal, at least in part, on the ground work George Lucas set down for him in 1977 with Han Solo, I’ll eat my entire science fiction collection.

Clearly, everybody’s lost but me.

Can we check the costume for just a second? Cross-slung holsters low over the hips, vest, blaster that looks more like an old six-shooter than anything else? You meet him a saloon, shortly followed by a gun fight, no less. (Han shoots first.) The man is a cowboy.

Amidst the tirade that flowed from my mouth directly at both these friends, one got a word in edgewise to note that Han Solo was more of a pirate. I’m not disregarding that. There are definitely pirate qualities to Han. I respect that. That point will be duly noted in my log.

But when it comes to space cowboys, Joss Whedon didn’t invent crap. And I’m a Joss fan. We know this. I’m wearing an “I Love Buffy” t-shirt as we speak and could probably recite every episode of Firefly verbatim. I would definitely say that Joss pushed the western-in-space genre to new levels, creating a very shiny verse rich in detail and some awesome characters that dwell within. A high contender for the best television series I’ve ever seen in my entire life. Certainly in the top five.
But I’m not budging on this point. And I think Mr. Whedon himself would bitch-slap you for the slight to the epic, society-changing, masterful storytelling that is Star Wars. (Episodes IV through VI, anyway.)

It is worth noting that both friends, to their credit, backpedaled and agreed with me once I made my very loud point, either because Han Solo had simply slipped their mind in the middle of a work day, or because they recognized the crazed emphasis in my yelling and feared for their safety. You decide. If you’ve got a contender that predates or out-cools Han Solo in the realms of film or television, leave a comment below and let me know. I’ll rail at you too.


As an aside, this whole debate was spurred by a conversation on the new James Marsters movie High Plains Invaders that is showing on the Sci-Fi Channel at the end of the month. I have no idea what that’s going to be like, but I might check it out. If I do, I’ll let you know what I think. As usual.

Comments

Submitted by Amy on

No, I'm only a Trekkie by marriage - so I could be wrong....but wasn't Star Trek supposed to be a western in space? Yeah - check this out:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Western and this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek

Submitted by swingbug on

That's a fair point. And while that may have been Roddenberry's intent, I'm not convinced he was successful in that regard. Don't get me wrong. Star Trek has its place in the universe, and its place is the crowning jewel in televised science fiction, at the very least. There are few who would argue, and I'm certainly not one of those.

I still stand by my declaration that Han Solo was the first space cowboy, though Amy presents a worthy discussion topic.

Submitted by Megs on

Duh, of course Han Solo predates Wheedon. I'm with you, Wheedon brought the genre back out into the open, but he certainly didn't "pioneer" it and you know how much I love this creative genius.

Submitted by Ania on

Thanks for alerting me to the, um, 'discussion'.

I will claim 'geek-in-training' status and keep my mouth shut.

(except to say, that my first thought after the 2nd paragraph was , 'huh ? Wasn't Star Wars (the original trilogy) kind of a space western ? Oh, well, what do I know, I'm no expert.".

Oh boy, this is a fun one! I know I'm totally late to the party, but as person old enough to remember the Middle Ages without use of a text-book, I humbly submit that Captain Kirk is probably the original Space Cowboy. Gunslinger, out in the badlands of space, lovin' and leaving all the pretty maids...Not to mention how cowboy Bones was, too....I love Han Solo, but....Kirk pre-dates him.